New Baltimore Ice Cream

Note: This is a user-generated website created for informational purposes, reviews, and feedback.

New Baltimore Ice Cream Alliance OH
New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream
New Baltimore Ice Cream

About New Baltimore Ice Cream

New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, nestled at 14738 Ravenna Ave NE, Alliance, OH, is a beloved local gem, cherished for its delectable homemade ice cream and welcoming atmosphere. This charming ice cream parlor, a true labor of love, is a family-owned business run by Tana Gerwin, alongside her daughter, Michele, and son-in-law, Sven Van Bulck. Stepping into New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is like stepping into a world of sweet dreams. The ice cream is lovingly crafted on-site, ensuring that every scoop is a fresh, delightful experience. What sets this place apart is the ever-changing array of small-batch ice cream flavors, guaranteeing a new adventure in every visit.

The generous portions and warm smiles from the staff add to the overall charm. Tana Gerwin’s journey with the shop began in 1992 when she and her late husband, Rick, became the proud owners. While Rick is no longer with it, the legacy lives on through the family, with Michele and her husband Sven, carrying the torch and keeping the New Baltimore Ice Cream tradition alive. This heartwarming family story is a testament to the enduring spirit of small, local businesses that bring communities together.

Menu at New Baltimore Ice Cream

At New Baltimore Ice Cream, located at 14738 Ravenna Ave NE, Alliance, OH, the menu is a sweet symphony of flavors that promises to satisfy every ice cream lover’s cravings. The ever-changing menu offers a delightful range of small-batch ice cream options, all made fresh on-site. With each visit, you can explore a new world of tastes as they rotate the flavors daily. From classic favorites like creamy vanilla and rich chocolate to inventive creations like salted caramel swirl and wild berry delight, there’s something for everyone.

Whether you prefer your ice cream in a cup, cone, or even a decadent sundae, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream has you covered. And if you’re a fan of mouthwatering milkshakes or creamy floats, you’re in for a treat. Don’t forget to ask about the seasonal specials and signature sundaes, which are sure to tickle your taste buds. With generous portions and a commitment to quality, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is the perfect destination for ice cream connoisseurs looking to embark on a sweet adventure.

View More
Outside New Baltimore Ice Cream
Menu at New Baltimore Ice Cream

A Symphony of Flavors at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

New Baltimore Ice Cream offers an enchanting menu that promises to tantalize your taste buds with a variety of mouthwatering options. At New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, every flavor is a work of art, carefully crafted to provide a one-of-a-kind ice cream experience. With a variety that caters to all tastes, you’re bound to find a flavor that suits your cravings. Whether you’re an adventurer seeking new taste horizons or a steadfast lover of the classics, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream has something special waiting for you.

Buckeye Brownie

Dive into a world of chocolatey bliss with this exquisite flavor. It features rich chocolate ice cream generously studded with delectable chunks of brownie and decadent buckeye frosting. If you’re a devoted chocolate lover, this is an absolute must-try.

Salted Caramel Pretzel

Indulge in the perfect balance of sweet and salty. This delightful option combines creamy salted caramel ice cream with swirls of pretzel pieces, offering a harmonious contrast in flavors and textures that’s utterly irresistible.

Lavender Honey

For those seeking a unique and refreshing choice, the Lavender Honey flavor is a revelation. Enjoy the subtle, floral notes of lavender ice cream, expertly balanced by the sweetness of honey. It’s a refreshing and invigorating choice, particularly on a scorching summer day.

Ambience at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream offers an ambiance that’s as delightful as the ice cream. The moment you step through the door, you’re greeted by a cheerful and welcoming atmosphere that instantly lifts your spirits. The walls are adorned in bright, vibrant colors, creating a sense of joy and playfulness. Scattered throughout are captivating pictures of luscious ice cream sundaes and a tempting array of other treats, a visual feast that sets the tone for the sweet adventure that awaits.

But the enchantment doesn’t stop there; the shop is adorned with a collection of ice cream-themed memorabilia, including vintage ice cream signs and scoops, adding a touch of nostalgia to the space. It’s a place where every corner exudes the love and passion that go into creating the homemade ice cream. At New Baltimore Ice Cream, the ambiance is just as delectable as the ice cream itself, making each visit a delightful experience.

Exceptional Services

New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream takes pride in offering exceptional services that go beyond just scooping ice cream. As you step into this charming establishment, you’ll be greeted by friendly and knowledgeable staff who are passionate about helping you find the perfect treat to satisfy your cravings.

The service here is not just about serving ice cream; it’s about creating memorable experiences for every visitor. Whether you’re a first-time guest or a regular patron, the team is always ready to assist you in choosing from the ever-changing menu of delectable flavors. Moreover, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream takes catering orders, ensuring that you can bring the scrumptious ice cream to your special events and celebrations. The commitment to serving the community extends beyond the storefront, making them a beloved local gem that’s not just about ice cream but also about making each visit a delightful and memorable experience.

View More

Affordable Indulgence

New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream offers a delightful range of ice cream options at prices that won’t break the bank. This family-owned gem believes that everyone should be able to savor the high-quality, homemade ice cream without worrying about the wallet. From classic flavors to innovative creations, the pricing ensures that you can enjoy generous scoops of ice cream without burning a hole in your pocket.

They offer options for various budgets, making it an accessible treat for individuals, couples, and families alike. This commitment to affordability is a testament to the dedication to serving the local community. Whether you’re in the mood for a simple scoop or an elaborate sundae, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream offers a taste of indulgence that’s easy on your finances. So, indulge in your favorite ice cream flavors without hesitation, as New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream promises not only great taste but also great value.

Convenient Payment Options

At New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, you’ll find an array of convenient payment options designed to make your visit hassle-free. Whether you’re indulging in a sweet treat for yourself or treating your family and friends to the delicious ice cream, the establishment offers flexibility when it comes to settling your bill. You can choose to pay with cash, making it a quick and traditional option. Credit and debit cards are also gladly accepted, ensuring that you can enjoy your favorite flavors without the need for cash. For added convenience, many patrons appreciate the option to use mobile payment apps, making transactions even more effortless. New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream’s commitment to making your visit as enjoyable as possible extends to the payment process, ensuring that you can savor the delectable ice cream with ease.

Rave Reviews

The ice cream parlor has garnered a loyal following of patrons who can’t help but share the enthusiastic praise. Visitors have raved about the rich and innovative flavors, praising the shop’s commitment to quality and taste. The cheerful and welcoming atmosphere, along with the friendly staff, has left an indelible mark on customers, creating an environment that encourages repeat visits. Reviewers frequently commend the generous portions and the affordability of this sweet indulgence, making it a family-friendly destination. As one navigates through the reviews, it becomes evident that New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream isn’t just an ice cream parlor; it’s a place that has created lasting memories for its customers, earning its place as a cherished local treasure. Whether you’re a first-timer or a long-time patron, the reviews affirm that New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is a place where every scoop is a little piece of happiness.

Marlburl ice cream stand.

Rated 5.0 out of 5
November 4, 2023

America’s best ice cream. My family has been around for many generations and still is. Extremely well advised

Avatar for Lamp post D
Lamp post D

Well-liked Ice Cream Parlor

Rated 5.0 out of 5
November 3, 2023

One warm afternoon, a few of us stopped on the way home. It was a wise decision! While my friends received a variety of tastes and were all overjoyed, I received a vanilla cone! They have generously sized cones!

Avatar for Barbara B
Barbara B

Fantastic Ice Cream!

Rated 5.0 out of 5
November 2, 2023

My spouse and I each had a “medium”-sized cone (I had the chocolate, she the butter pecan). They were so enormous that I’m not sure how we handled them! Excellent value for the cost as well! Strongly advised!

Avatar for Shaun M
Shaun M

The best gelato

Rated 5.0 out of 5
November 1, 2023

This ice cream parlor is amazing. Enormous portions. Although there are occasionally long lineups, the service is prompt and effective.

Avatar for Nitrous74
Nitrous74

Best Ice Cream Made at Home

Rated 5.0 out of 5
October 30, 2023

Unbeatable prices! Huge portions of ice cream with a weekly rotating selection of six to eight flavors. The local kids who work there are friendly and I love to tip them to hear their hollers.

Avatar for Carey D
Carey D

Please read more reviews about this restaurant on TripAdvisor & Yelp!

Connect with New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

If you’re eager to experience the sweet delights and warm ambiance of New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, reaching out is a breeze. You can find them at the charming location. Whether you’re looking to inquire about the delectable menu, catering options, or you simply want to share your love for the ice cream, the friendly staff at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream are always ready to assist you. You can give them a call to discuss any questions or special requests you might have. If you prefer the convenience of digital communication, consider sending them an email to connect and plan your visit. Stay updated on the latest flavors and seasonal specials by following the social media accounts. New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is more than just an ice cream parlor; it’s a community where every visitor is welcomed with open arms. So, don’t hesitate to get in touch and embark on a sweet journey with this beloved local gem.

Location 1

Location 2